TSM's defeat raises questions about committing to League of Legends


For Team SoloMid, 2016 has been a rollercoaster. The team slumped down to sixth place during the regular spring split, at a time when the roster was stacked with veteran talent. They entered the playoffs in the lowest bracket, wounded but not yet defeated. They ended up fighting to the end, taking out spring favourites Immortals in a decisive 3-0 series and only falling to Counter Logic Gaming in the final best of five. Their failure only seemed to fuel Team SoloMid, and they were the dominant North American powerhouse of summer. They dropped only one game during the entire split, and easily took the first seed. Team SoloMid have been talking about their ambitions at Worlds for years; this was the first time that they actually looked in shape to make those dreams a reality.

They failed. TSM fell one game short of making it out of their group. On one hand, this year is still a success—they showed dramatic improvements over their week two collapse in 2015. Baby steps are bittersweet when you consider the amount of work and time that TSM invested. They even held off on streaming, a lucrative deal for them, to focus on Worlds. Now that TSM have reached the end of their 2016 journey, it’s time to examine the questions they leave in their wake. After a year of work, and with another year ahead before they get another opportunity to prove themselves at Worlds, it’s time to examine the competitive format.

Photo credit: Riot Games

Photo credit: Riot Games

The burden of fault

It’s important to note that the format of Worlds, the amount of international events, Riot’s prize pool system, or anything does not remove the burden of fault from Team SoloMid. Ultimately, it was up to them to win enough games to qualify for the quarterfinals; they were unable to do this. Any member of team would admit that they are at fault, and they alone.

With that out of the way, it’s easy to see how TSM could get discouraged. They leave Worlds with signs of improvement but no tangible rewards. They gave up streaming revenue, and sunk a large amount of sheer time and effort into the endeavor. It’s one thing to get back up and prime yourself for the next tournament, but it could be months before TSM gets the chance to compete on another international stage. There are only a few events: Worlds, the Intel Extreme Masters series, and the Mid Season Invitational. Other than that, it’s back to the NA LCS.

Photo credit: Riot Games

Photo credit: Riot Games

International opportunities

There’s certainly an argument to be made that the number of international tournaments should be increased. There are a few issues that come from having clashes between regions be so rare: there’s always an awkward first week as each region adapts to each other's metas, the narrative of how they performed at Worlds defines them for weeks or months, and it creates fewer opportunities to watch teams outside a fan’s home region.

It’s also important to note how much time has to go into the regional circuits. A split is nine straight weeks of competition, and then there’s the playoffs. Even more exhausting is the fact that early play doesn’t necessarily mean extra practice; the changing metagame prevents that. Patches and meta changes mean that a team can be playing a very different game at the beginning and end of a season. If a player practices their hardest throughout all of this, they may rapidly find themselves without any gas in the tank.

Choices and consequences

This is a question that may be sacrilege to many fans, but it must be asked: is there any reason for TSM not to coast through spring and maybe summer? If they come home after this defeat and continue to push themselves to the absolute limits, would that be a clever use of resources or just sheer stubbornness? Team SoloMid is one of the biggest brands in esports: they don’t have to worry about continuing to accumulate or maintain a fanbase. Streaming and merchandise and sponsorships could continue to fill their coffers while they do just enough to avoid the danger zone for a team come spring. After the sorrow of a loss, and the knowledge that it could take months to get back on the stage, it could be a tempting option.

Photo credit: Riot Games

Photo credit: Riot Games

Work smarter, not harder

Team SoloMid is such a fascinating case for these questions because despite all of their hard work, all of their time, and even the wall they hit at Worlds, it still doesn’t seem like they’re interested in taking up the above hypothetical. Mid laner Bjergsen has been vocal about the fact that he wants to keep getting better and competing at the highest level, and the rest of the team seems to be ready to follow in his footsteps.

It sounds corny to say that the competitive spirit is the reason that teams continue to drive themselves, that there may not be tangible reasons but just sheer force of will. At the same time, it seems to be the main reason why TSM are pushing themselves.

Now, the question becomes how they can achieve greater results without just pouring in more effort. TSM has worked hard and sacrificed much, the answer isn’t ‘do that more’—that’s a good way to burnout and cause greater problems. This is a puzzle that many League teams are going to have to face in the future. How can you improve within your region without spending every waking hour playing? 

TSM has often been on the vanguard of new developments in esports. While 2016 has ended on a sour note, I suspect that it’s the beginning of some changes to the way the western scene handles coaching and internal infrastructure. It’s hard to tell what, exactly, TSM plans to do next, but one thing is clear: they won’t give up.

Latest in MOBA
League of Legends promo image - huge dude in a huge suit of armor holding a huge axe
Riot walks back unpopular League of Legends changes: Hextech Chests are coming back, and the Blue Essence cost for new champions will be cut in half
A triptych of views from Deadlock's improved map, showing a suspension bridge backlit by a setting sun, a triumphal arch with buildings in the background, and a leafy park overlooked by distant skyscrapers.
Deadlock gets a massive map overhaul that shrinks its map from four lanes to three: 'This has a large range of accompanying map-wide changes'
Three monsters holding clubs in Dota 2.
As a lapsed 4,500 hour veteran of Dota 2, the big new Wandering Waters update has lured me back—but despite the changes, the game still feels stuck in its ways
Sahn-Uzal Mordekaiser revealed in silhouette against a white moon and a blood-red sky.
League of Legends is getting a hotly anticipated skin for its lich necromancer Mordekaiser, but fans' joy has been 'obliterated' because it's 'stuck in a $200 fomo gacha store'
Smite 2 art
Hi-Rez will only be giving 'minor updates' to Smite and Paladins now it's laying off around 70 employees, but don't worry, Smite 2 is the 'primary focus of the newly streamlined operations'
LoL summoner art
It's high time League of Legends got full voice chat
Latest in Features
Geralt, two swords on his back, in the wilderness
2011 was an amazing comeback year for PC gaming
Alligator skull with glowing eyes on human body and cords coming out sitting at piano with "The Norwood Etudes" ready to play
My new most anticipated RPG let me be a kleptomaniac gourmand set loose in a noir city on a quest to make 'the perfect sandwich'
Monster Hunter Wilds' stockpile master studying a manifest
Monster Hunter Wilds' new gyro controls are a fantastic option for disabled and able-bodied players alike
Manhunt 2
I played the notoriously ratings-board-ravaged Manhunt 2 and was quite glad for the censorship actually
A busy marketplace in The Bazaar.
The Bazaar could be the future of autobattlers, if it stops strangling itself to death with its own microtransactions
Marvel Rivals characters - Hulk with his hands out as if he's grabbing the camera.
Marvel Rivals' growing roster of heroes scares me, but the game's director seems sure that all is under control: 'Everything is progressing smoothly'