Starfield High Price to Pay guide: Should you stay at the Lodge or go to The Eye?

The Hunter, a character in Starfield, stands with his helmet on
(Image credit: Bethesda)

As part of the main quest in Starfield, you'll need to make a difficult decision that will affect the future of your new space pals in Constellation. We're still figuring out all the possible outcomes here, but it does seem clear that whoever you're romancing and/or spending the most time with does affect the outcome. This guide contains spoilers for the first major decision in Starfield so if you'd rather go in blind, tab away now. 

Should you stay at the Lodge or go to The Eye? 

As you progress through Starfield's main campaign you'll begin a quest called High Price to Pay. The Eye, Constellation's satellite office of sorts, is under attack by The Hunter, a member of the mysterious Starborn who are none too pleased about you pinching Artifacts and gathering powers. Half of your companions are at the Lodge and half are on The Eye, so you need to decide whether you're going to stay and defend the Lodge or head up to The Eye to save the wounded.

There are several points to consider when making this decision, with the major outcome being someone will die. Who you spend the most time with or are possibly romancing seems to make a bit of a difference, but here are the outcomes we've had so far. 

  • Go to The Eye, romancing Sam: Sarah dies
  • Go to The Eye, romancing Andreja: Sam dies
  • Defend the Lodge, romancing Andreja: Andreja dies
  • Go to The Eye, Barrett dies

These seem to be the four characters at risk of dying, though it's unclear how much of a relationship you need to have with them to save them if you choose to go or stay where they aren't. If you want your romance option to live, I suggest heading to wherever they are, otherwise, you might as well line up a second option. You're going to encounter The Hunter and his nonsense either way, so it's best to be prepared. You'll be able to grab your late colleague's belongings from the basement, i.e. all the stuff you handed to them so you wouldn't be over-encumbered. 

Starfield guideStarfield endingStarfield companionsStarfield romance optionsStarfield console commandsStarfield mods

Starfield guide: Our hub of advice
Starfield ending: Who to side with
Starfield companions: All your recruitable crew
Starfield romance options: Space dating
Starfield console commands: Every cheat you need
Starfield mods: Space is your sandbox

TOPICS
Guides Editor

The first three games Lauren played on PC were Star Wars: X-Wing, Zoo Tycoon and Barbie Fashion Designer, which explains her love of all things space, strategy and aesthetically pleasing. Lauren recently took over as PC Gamer's Guides Editor after three years of writing many dozens of Destiny 2 guides at VG247, as well as casually trying to shoehorn in The Witcher 3 articles wherever possible. When she's not trying to force everyone to play as a Warlock in Destiny 2, Lauren is either mastering her SEO abilities to help smash the competition, or patting one of her red sons.

Read more
Avowed kill or spare Ygwulf - An upper-body shot of Ygwulf facing directly ahead.
Should you kill or spare Ygwulf in Avowed?
Avowed art showing companions having a picnic together under sunny day
All the Avowed ending choices and epilogue-affecting decisions
Avowed - Ilora speaking to the player
Should you free or leave Ilora in Avowed?
Henry and Radzig stand side-by-side, Henry looks shocked and Radzig looks proud.
How to get the best ending in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2
Dry Devil holds a torch, illuminating a creepy rictus grin on his face.
Should you let Dry Devil burn Maleshov in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2?
Avowed Sargamis choice - An upper-body shot of Sargamis looking almost directly ahead.
Should you give Sargamis the relic in Avowed?
Latest in RPG
Person battling bizarre four-eyed monster with stylish UI elements surrounding them
Persona and Metaphor: ReFantazio's UI designer is open to accessibility options for players who find the stylish menus overstimulating: 'That is something we understand we'll need to work on and provide in the future'
Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth money farm - Super Crazy Delivery
Like a Dragon series director sums up why sidequests are essential to a great RPG with a single metaphor: 'a good main dish alone will not earn you a Michelin star'
Image of a sweetroll with a candle in it
Bethesda marks Oblivion's 19th with a sweetroll, a candle, and absolutely no happy birthday gift for fans eager for the still-unannounced remaster
Fallout 76 ghoul screenshots
Getting to level 50 in Fallout 76 to become a ghoul actually isn't as daunting as it seems, which is why I created a new character
Koana, a main character in Final Fantasy 14: Dawntrail, stares thoughtfully at a book in his hands.
After a controversial coding slip-up fed stalkers info on their victim's alts, FF14 wipes the slate clean to try and fix its mistakes
Scorched person with their hands on their head
Ghoul players in Fallout 76 are starting to place their camps in the most radioactive areas of the map, and regular humans aren't happy: 'I had to inject 30+ radaway into my veins'
Latest in Features
Fragpunk
Somebody finally figured out casual Counter-Strike
Dean Hall at GDC 2025.
Outer space inspired DayZ's Dean Hall to become a modder and game developer, and now he's making a Kerbal successor called Kitten Space Agency
An image of a corpse with the text "You've been re-educated."
I played the lost videogame sequel to 1984, and came away more nostalgic than ever for gaming's awkward adolescence in 1999
Bears in Space
I downloaded this bear-obsessed comedy FPS to kill time before Doom: The Dark Ages and discovered the most underrated shooter on Steam
Fallout 76 ghoul screenshots
Getting to level 50 in Fallout 76 to become a ghoul actually isn't as daunting as it seems, which is why I created a new character
A man turns away from an open window while monsters gather in the dark
Look Outside is a survival horror RPG where you absolutely should not look outside