'Segregating high skill players from the population at large, forcing long wait times on them, is a form of discrimination': former Halo multiplayer lead on the 'failure' of SBMM in modern games

halo 3
(Image credit: Microsoft)

If you ever want to toss a discourse grenade into a room and watch the sparks fly, bring up skill-based matchmaking. How much or little developers should factor player skill into who you're permitted to play against in multiplayer games is an evergreen debate of our hobby, but it's not everyday that an expert on the topic chimes in.

Responding to an opinion piece in PLAY Magazine about SBMM in FPSes (as shared by GamesRadar) on Twitter, former Bungie multiplayer lead Max Hoberman argues modern multiplayer games do a "disservice" to players by only serving them even matchups, citing his work on Halo 3 as how to do matchmaking right.

"Ranked filtered opponents based on level. This was for when you wanted a competitive match," said Hoberman in a tweet thread. "But even then, I intentionally allowed variability in the range of levels we matched you with."

Hoberman, who was the multiplayer and online lead on Halo 2 and Halo 3 before founding Certain Affinity in 2006, laid out the three types of matches that Halo's matchmaker was designed to serve players: an "easier" match you were likely to win, a "harder" one where you were outmatched, and an even matchup.

"The failure of modern skill-based matchmaking, imho, is that it's designed to maximize these perfect match scenarios and minimize the others," he said. "When it's working, a majority of games become super tight, super stressful. That's not fun for most players. Where's the variability?"

Hoberman's perspective on SBMM cuts against the common wisdom in competitive games that creating fair matches, and only fair matches, produces the best results. The most popular competitive games in the world—Counter-Strike 2, Dota 2, League of Legends, Apex Legends, Rainbow Six Siege—all use ELO or MMR-based ranking systems to always attempt to form balanced lobbies. This often means that the majority of players can quickly find matches, but the top 10% of players have to wait a lot longer.

"Segregating high skill players from the population at large, forcing long wait times on them, is a form of discrimination," he said. "Designers should strive to find a way that players of all skill levels can have fun together."

One way, Hoberman says, is to have designed skill variance in unranked and ranked modes. Most games already do this in unranked scenarios: casual playlists often prioritize finding matches quickly over finding players of similar skill, or even establish a separate MMR for unranked versus ranked. What almost all multiplayer games have in common is that casual MMR values are hidden.

A damaged sci-fi jeep dodges plasma rounds from an alien tank

(Image credit: Microsoft)

Hoberman's argument for variance is intriguing, but it also strikes me as incomplete. To many players, a huge part of the appeal of competitive games is to definitively prove their skill against the rest of the community. There's a real sense of accomplishment in reaching a high rank in CS2 or League of Legends, and part of what makes that accomplishment feel genuine is knowing the game tries to give you a fair challenge at every step of the way. I reckon if you asked players deeply embedded in those communities if they'd prefer to be deliberately given unfair matchups part of the time, they'd probably say no. The promise of unfair matches in your favor to balance things out does sound fun, but also pandering in a way that could spoil the glory.

On the flipside, Hoberman's vision for SBMM is exactly what the most vocal corners of the Call of Duty community constantly ask for.

"The system that I designed for Ranked playlists ensured a healthy mix. Sure, it sucks watching your favorite team get their butt kicked," he said. "But it comes full circle when they're the ones kicking butt. Throw in tight, evenly matched games every so often, and that's a ton of fun."

modern warfare 3

(Image credit: Activision Blizzard)

Activision generally doesn't comment on how its SBMM works, but we know it's there in CoD, and we know that many players think its SBMM is too sweaty, or report huge fluctuations in the perceived skill of their opponents from match to match, resulting in a frustrating whiplash between getting stomped and doing the stomping. This gives the impression that there is some skill variance baked into CoD's matchmaker, but that it's not totally random, and generally favors a fair match.

Whether or not these complaints are backed up by data, they've made SBMM a hot-button issue for the series in recent years, with a vocal majority arguing against fair matchups in favor of a Hoberman-style of "fair" where everyone has an equal chance to have a bad or good time. Except, there are disproportionate winners and losers in that scenario, too: the top 1% skilled players have a 99% chance of finding an easy match, while the bottom 1% are likely to have a bad time every time.

I'm not sure how Hoberman's system accounts for these players. If the highest-skill players really do get an even match "every so often," does that mean sometimes their matchmaking times are 30 seconds and other times 5-10 minutes? Because that can be how long it takes to find a good matchup when you're among the best.

It's no surprise that developers opt to obfuscate the particulars of their matchmaking systems. There's no pleasing everybody, especially when some want fairness by way of skill ratings and others want fairness via an amorphous illusion of randomness. Hoberman's full Twitter thread, which includes more thoughts on casual matchmaking, is worth a read.

Morgan Park
Staff Writer

Morgan has been writing for PC Gamer since 2018, first as a freelancer and currently as a staff writer. He has also appeared on Polygon, Kotaku, Fanbyte, and PCGamesN. Before freelancing, he spent most of high school and all of college writing at small gaming sites that didn't pay him. He's very happy to have a real job now. Morgan is a beat writer following the latest and greatest shooters and the communities that play them. He also writes general news, reviews, features, the occasional guide, and bad jokes in Slack. Twist his arm, and he'll even write about a boring strategy game. Please don't, though.

Read more
marvel rivals
Competitive shooters are at a crucial crossroads in 2025: 'sweaty' teamplay vs. casual fun
black ops 6 season 1
Activision will send you alarmingly detailed data for every single Call of Duty match you've played in the last 4 years if you ask, and players are using it to figure out their mysterious SBMM rankings
marvel rivals characters screenshots
'The team wants every kind of player to enjoy the game': Marvel Rivals director wants to foster a competitive scene, but not at the expense of fun
Ghost, from Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 (2022), looks bleakly at a fellow passenger in a transport.
For COD’s sake: One player’s 763-day legal quest to make Activision unban their account ends in total success: ‘Worth the effort’
Thor charging up his hammer.
I've navigated Marvel Rivals' chaotic ranked play and dragged myself out of Plat hell, which means it's time to start preparing to do it all over again next season
Mister Fantastic giving a thumbs up
'Who planned this garbage?' Streamers unite in slamming the official Twitch Marvel Rivals tournament for last-minute rule changes and unbalanced chaos
Latest in Games
Naoe looking at the wrist blade in Assassin's Creed Shadows
Ubisoft backflips, says Assassin's Creed Shadows will support Steam Deck at launch, but I doubt I'll actually want to play it there
Henry from KCD2 wearing nice outfits
'Diversify your fashion endgame' with this Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 mod that gives Henry fly new gambesons, pourpoints, and caftans
Masked Counter-Terrorist in helmet in forefront with sunglasses and beret-wearing CT in background touching headset
There's hope yet for Classic Offensive after its Steam rejection: The team behind the Counter-Strike 1.6 revival mod is in touch with Valve about its 'concerns'
Orithopter shooting down another in Dune
Dune: Awakening confirms air-to-air combat in ornithopters
Inzoi - A Zoi's face in three graphical presets showing a progression from a slightly blurry minimum specs to a higher fidelity recommended specs.
Oh great, the full Inzoi system requirements are posted and I'm barely above the minimum specs so I guess my Zois will be beautifully blurry
Mark Darrah
BioWare veteran says a big delay is better than lots of little ones, because sometimes you just gotta 'burn it down and take the other fork in the road'
Latest in News
Naoe looking at the wrist blade in Assassin's Creed Shadows
Ubisoft backflips, says Assassin's Creed Shadows will support Steam Deck at launch, but I doubt I'll actually want to play it there
Henry from KCD2 wearing nice outfits
'Diversify your fashion endgame' with this Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 mod that gives Henry fly new gambesons, pourpoints, and caftans
Masked Counter-Terrorist in helmet in forefront with sunglasses and beret-wearing CT in background touching headset
There's hope yet for Classic Offensive after its Steam rejection: The team behind the Counter-Strike 1.6 revival mod is in touch with Valve about its 'concerns'
Recently appointed Intel CEO Lip-Bu Tan.
Here comes Intel's new CEO: a semiconductor veteran that won the same prestigious award as Jensen Huang and Lisa Su
BURBANK, CALIFORNIA - AUGUST 15: Protestors attend the SAG-AFTRA Video Game Strike Picket on August 15, 2024 in Burbank, California. (Photo by Lila Seeley/Getty Images)
8 months into their strike, videogame voice actors say the industry's latest proposal is 'filled with alarming loopholes that will leave our members vulnerable to AI abuse'
Orithopter shooting down another in Dune
Dune: Awakening confirms air-to-air combat in ornithopters