'We had a very big debate, and I showed him. He was silent. He doesn't know how to make a battery': The founder of the world's biggest battery company apparently had a lesson or two to give Elon Musk

Elon Musk at the EEI 2023 event in Austin, Texas, US, on Tuesday, June 13, 2023.
(Image credit: Bloomberg (Getty Images))

Have you ever had one of those moments where, mid-debate, you suddenly realise you've lost the argument? If you're anything like me, you'll buy your editor another drink and pretend it was a draw. If you're Elon Musk, however, and you're standing in a factory debating the merits of your battery tech with the founder of the biggest EV battery maker in the world, I imagine it's a bit more toe-curling.

Musk appears to have found himself in just such a situation back in April, when he visited Robin Zeng at the CATL facility in Beijing (via Reuters). According to Zeng, he told Musk that his bet on the cylindrical battery found in the Cybertruck, the 4680, "is going to fail and never be successful."

"We had a very big debate, and I showed him," Zeng said. "He was silent. He doesn't know how to make a battery. It's about electrochemistry. He's good for the chips, the software, the hardware, the mechanical things."

Zeng didn't stop there, either. According to the company founder, he then moved on to question Musk's approach to product timelines.

"His problem is overpromising," Zeng said. "I talked to him. Maybe something needs five years. But he says two years. I definitely asked him why. He told me he wanted to push people.

"He probably himself thinks it needs five years, but if you believe him when he says two years, you will be in big trouble. The direction is right."

Don't hold back, Zeng, tell us what you really think. Still, there are some compliments dotted in among all that critique. After all, no one's top dog at everything, and it sounds like Mr Zeng here took Elon to task in the way a good mentor mightbalancing useful knowledge with direct critique, even if it does come out a little blunt in his own retelling.

And Robin Zeng knows a thing or two about batteries and company management, that's for sure. CATL, short for Contemporary Amperex Technology Limited., is estimated to be the worlds biggest manufacturer of batteries, including automotive efforts that power electric cars from Volkswagen, BMW, and, err, Tesla.

Reports from this summer suggested that Musk might be prepared to give up on the Tesla 4680 battery cell by the end of the year. The original design brief was to create a battery that enabled Telsa to achieve a higher volume of electric vehicle production for a lower cost.

However, insider sources have said that the battery has multiple issues, and Tesla engineers were given a strict deadline to fix it.

More recent reports suggest that production had doubled between June and September of this year, so those issues might be behind the EV manufacturer now. Still, it seems like Mr Zeng remains unimpressed, so time will tell as to whether the 4680 battery becomes one of Musk's great achievements, or as Zeng thinks, a product destined for failure.

In the meantime, could one of these great minds do something about gaming handheld battery life? My Steam Deck is a wonderful thing, but if I could buy a handheld with more than a couple of hours worth of demanding runtime, my life would be complete. Please and thank you, and all that.

Best CPU for gamingBest gaming motherboardBest graphics cardBest SSD for gaming


Best CPU for gaming: Top chips from Intel and AMD.
Best gaming motherboard: The right boards.
Best graphics card: Your perfect pixel-pusher awaits.
Best SSD for gaming: Get into the game first.

Andy Edser
Hardware Writer

Andy built his first gaming PC at the tender age of 12, when IDE cables were a thing and high resolution wasn't—and he hasn't stopped since. Now working as a hardware writer for PC Gamer, Andy's been jumping around the world attending product launches and trade shows, all the while reviewing every bit of PC hardware he can get his hands on. You name it, if it's interesting hardware he'll write words about it, with opinions and everything.

Read more
Bill Gates speaks onstage for a special conversation during "What’s Next? The Future With Bill Gates"at The Paris Theater on September 26, 2024 in New York City.
Bill Gates laments Pat Gelsinger's failure to save Intel: 'I was hoping for his sake, for the country's sake that he would be successful'
WASHINGTON, DC - NOVEMBER 13: Elon Musk listens as U.S. President-elect Donald Trump addresses a House Republicans Conference meeting at the Hyatt Regency on Capitol Hill on November 13, 2024 in Washington, DC. As is tradition with incoming presidents, Trump is traveling to Washington, DC to meet with U.S. President Joe Biden at the White House as well as meet with Republican congressmen on Capitol Hill. (Photo by Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)
Elon Musk and Asmongold are beefing over who the best gamer really is, and no matter who wins, we lose
The Steam Deck playing Cyberpunk 2077, outside in a much-too-small back garden
The latest Steam Deck beta update can improve battery life with the frame limiter active by *checks notes* a whole six percent
ARM logo exhibited at ARM stand during the Mobile World Congress (MWC).
'There are lots of tombstones of great tech companies that didn’t reinvent themselves,' says Arm CEO Rene Haas of Intel's recent woes
Intel's Raja Koduri holding an A770
Ex-Intel exec, Raja Koduri, blames the bureaucratic 'PowerPoint snakes' within the company for its current issues: 'These processes multiply and coil around engineers'
Nvidia's Jen-Hsun Huang
Nvidia's corporate blog goes full fan mode with its description of Jen-Hsun Huang: 'Tech Leader, AI Visionary, Endlessly Curious'
Latest in Hardware
Nvidia RTX 5080 Founders Edition graphics card from different angles
Nvidia says it really has sorted RTX 50-series black screen issues this time around as yet another driver fix finds its way to release
A collection of upturned CDs, DVDs and Blu-Rays on a carpeted floor
Warner Bros says it will replace certain DVDs damaged by 'disc rot', but you might not get the same movie you sent in for replacement
Skytech Shadow gaming PC on a blue background
Screw waiting for GPU restocks, with an AMD RX 9070 gaming PC going for as cheap as this I'd hop on the pre-built bandwagon
A screenshot from a YouTube video showing a sticker being pulled from the front of a fake 9800X3D CPU
This Amazon-bought fake AMD Ryzen 7 9800X3D is actually a 14-year-old Bulldozer chip with a cheap sticker on it
OneXPlayer 2 pro on a table
I never thought a handheld PC bloated with Windows could replace my Steam Deck, but after gaming on an old OneXPlayer 2 Pro I can see now I judged it too harshly
Asus ROG Swift PG27UCDM gaming monitor
Asus ROG Swift PG27UCDM review
Latest in News
Pedro Pascal as Joel in a coat in winter looking unhappy
'Don't you know what he did?': The truth comes out in The Last of Us Season 2 trailer
Aloy
'Creepy,' 'ghastly,' 'rancid': Viewers react to leaked video of Sony's AI-powered Aloy
Split Fiction trailer still - Zoe and Mio standing side by side, wearing glowing neon sci-fi jammies
Split Fiction sells 1 million copies over 2 days
A soldier looks out over the Verdansk map, as a single tear rolls down his cheek.
The original Verdansk map is returning to Call of Duty: Warzone, to celebrate which we get a soldier crying to Nat King Cole
More than 5 years after launch, Control gets a surprise patch that lets everyone play the Hideo Kojima mission
Swen Vincke
Swen Vincke stamps seal of approval on Stardew Valley mod that yoinks the Baldur's Gate 3 cast out of D&D and into a cosy pastoral life