'The ongoing conversations around ARM vs x86 power are based on a false premise,' says Intel's VP of technical marketing

Intel's Lunar Lake Lion Cove cores without Hyper-Threading
(Image credit: Intel)

Which is more power-savvy, ARM or x86? Anyone familiar with today's chip line-up would probably respond with: 'Easy, ARM. Just look at the battery life on some of those Snapdragon X Elite laptops, you doughnut.'

But is that really the case? Unsurprisingly, the company responsible for designing most of the world's x86 chips, Intel, thinks it's not.

Robert Hallock has plenty of experience with x86, and talking up its benefits. He's currently Intel's VP of Technical Marketing and held a similar role at AMD for many years prior. Only Intel and AMD are able to produce x86 chips (ignoring VIA). Any other company with a desire to produce chips tends to use foundations laid out and licensed by Arm. Or RISC-V, though that's another story.

"It is our firm belief that the ongoing conversations around ARM vs. x86 power are based on a false premise because it is not the instruction set architecture (ISA) that broadly dictates power," Hallock says to Notebookcheck.

"Our view is a physical one: transistors cost power. A CPU design that adds core counts, increases NPU size, increases graphics size, or adds fabric complexity is not free. These decisions intrinsically raise package power consumption and TDPs into the ballpark of what consumers historically see from conventional Windows/Linux processors.

"In other words: implementing the features and performance the market expects has a 'typical cost,' regardless of the x86 or ARM ISA. So, if adding complexity costs power on any ISA, then it becomes a battle between which set of design choices yields the best performance/power/area (PPA) to meet consumer expectations."

ARM designs are seen to be more power-efficient than x86, at least in the products they're shipped within: you have Apple's own designs, Arm processors in phones, and the latest Snapdragon X Elite chips that have made their way into heaps of laptops recently. Generally, all devices that are known for decent battery life.

On the other hand, x86 goes into power-hungry desktop chips and servers. Though also many ultra-thin laptops.

Hallock goes on to talk about Lunar Lake, the next generation of mobile chips that are dedicated to slimming power budgets. Over at a Lunar Lake architecture briefing, Hallock also said similar things about what makes a chip power-efficient, and what doesn't.

"It is not x86, it is not ARM that determines power," Hallock told us at the event in May, "it is the physical design of the chip. It is the floor plan of the chip. It is the process technology used, the packaging technology used. It is relentlessly optimising every component in that platform, one watt panels, the most efficient memory, the most efficient SSDs. That is what drives battery life. That is what drives CPU power."

"So what you will see from Lunar Lake is x86 powered like you have never seen it before. We relentlessly tackled every single execution engine in this chip to extract the most performance per watt that we could. We touched everything. Graphics, packaging, cores, fabric, every component received an improvement."

Intel slides on its latest processor, Luna Lake.

(Image credit: Future)

So, is it the ISA that's really responsible for power saving? Intel says no, but we can also turn to comments from renowned chip designer Jim Keller for some insightful thoughts. 

Keller suggested in a conversation with TechTechPotato three years ago now that any architecture could be pretty power-efficient. However, this changes with time. 

Over the years, ISAs get filled with more and more stuff. Some stuff you need, some stuff you don't need so much, some stuff is just a bit rubbish—you have to keep most of it if you want to ensure backwards compatibility with older software and systems. The older the ISA, the more stuff in there potentially making it less efficient.

x86 is quite old now, it was first introduced in the late '70s. There's a lot of stuff.

Your next upgrade

Nvidia RTX 4070 and RTX 3080 Founders Edition graphics cards

(Image credit: Future)

Best CPU for gaming: The top chips from Intel and AMD.
Best gaming motherboard: The right boards.
Best graphics card: Your perfect pixel-pusher awaits.
Best SSD for gaming: Get into the game ahead of the rest.

"So, when ARM first came out it was a clean 32-bit computer and compared to x86 it looked just way simpler and easier to build," Keller says. "But then they added a 16-bit mode and the IT instruction, which was awful, and that sort of weird floating point vector extension set with overlays in the registry file, and then 64-bit, which partially cleaned it up. Then they added some special stuff for security and booting. So it's only got more complicated.

"Now RISC-V shows up and it's the shiny new cousin. There's no legacy and it's actually an open instruction set architecture. And people build it in universities where they don't have time and interest to add too much junk like some architectures have."

Now we're touching on a wider subject here, general efficiency between multiple architectures—which is better, x86, ARM, or RISC-V? I'm not going to talk about that here. But clearly there's something to be said for the simplicity of a newer architecture—the less junk in the ISA, the better. 

Though there's a reason we don't game on RISC-V, it doesn't have enough stuff just yet. The ecosystem isn't there, yet. Furthermore, process node, transistors (and how power is delivered to them), substrates and what's actually on the chip(s) play an inarguably large role in determining power draw for any specific device—it's really all about getting the balance right between the lot.

Jacob Ridley
Managing Editor, Hardware

Jacob earned his first byline writing for his own tech blog. From there, he graduated to professionally breaking things as hardware writer at PCGamesN, and would go on to run the team as hardware editor. He joined PC Gamer's top staff as senior hardware editor before becoming managing editor of the hardware team, and you'll now find him reporting on the latest developments in the technology and gaming industries and testing the newest PC components.

Read more
Qualcomm Snapdragon X Elite logo on a Samsung laptop
Eight months into the brave new world of Windows on ARM, and this is the state of play for PC gaming outside of the x86 arena
ARM logo exhibited at ARM stand during the Mobile World Congress (MWC).
'There are lots of tombstones of great tech companies that didn’t reinvent themselves,' says Arm CEO Rene Haas of Intel's recent woes
Qualcomm Snapdragon X Elite logo on a Samsung laptop
Next-gen Snapdragon X2 chip rumoured to pack 18 cores and a new CPU architecture, but we're still waiting for gaming to really be a goer on the original Snapdragon X
Bill Gates speaks onstage for a special conversation during "What’s Next? The Future With Bill Gates"at The Paris Theater on September 26, 2024 in New York City.
Bill Gates laments Pat Gelsinger's failure to save Intel: 'I was hoping for his sake, for the country's sake that he would be successful'
ARM logo exhibited at ARM stand during the Mobile World Congress (MWC).
Arm reportedly plans to make its own CPUs from this summer with future chips said to be powering a revolutionary Jony Ive-designed AI device
Intel's Lunar Lake Lion Cove cores without Hyper-Threading
The future of the PC according to Intel is a CPU-GPU-NPU trifecta and that definitely includes gaming
Latest in Processors
 photo shows a factory tool that places lids on data center system-on-chips at an Intel fab in Chandler, Arizona, in December 2023. In February 2024, Intel Corporation launched Intel Foundry as the world’s first systems foundry for the AI era, delivering leadership in technology, resiliency and sustainability.
Return of the gigahertz wars: New Chinese transistor uses bismuth instead of silicon to potentially sock it to Intel and TSMC with 40% more speed
 photo shows a factory tool that places lids on data center system-on-chips at an Intel fab in Chandler, Arizona, in December 2023. In February 2024, Intel Corporation launched Intel Foundry as the world’s first systems foundry for the AI era, delivering leadership in technology, resiliency and sustainability.
So, wait, now TSMC is supposedly pitching a joint venture with Nvidia, AMD and Broadcom to run Intel's ailing chip fabs?
Pipboy holds up an open padlock.
A BIOS update could be all that's stopping you or someone else from jailbreaking your old AMD CPU
A screenshot from Sony's PlayStation 5 Pro announcement video, showing a stylized processor against a dark background with glowing lines streaming from its edges
The AMD x Sony collab gave us FSR4 and a version will appear in PlayStation next year, too, having 'already started to implement the new neural network on PS5 Pro'
A screenshot from a YouTube video showing a sticker being pulled from the front of a fake 9800X3D CPU
This Amazon-bought fake AMD Ryzen 7 9800X3D is actually a 14-year-old Bulldozer chip with a cheap sticker on it
A close-up stylized photo of a silicon wafer, showing many small processor dies
Intel is still using TSMC for 30% of its wafer demands: 'We were talking about trying to get that to zero as quickly as possible. That's no longer the strategy'
Latest in News
Henry from KCD2 wearing nice outfits
'Diversify your fashion endgame' with this Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 mod that gives Henry fly new gambesons, pourpoints, and caftans
Masked Counter-Terrorist in helmet in forefront with sunglasses and beret-wearing CT in background touching headset
There's hope yet for Classic Offensive after its Steam rejection: The team behind the Counter-Strike 1.6 revival mod is in touch with Valve about its 'concerns'
Recently appointed Intel CEO Lip-Bu Tan.
Here comes Intel's new CEO: a semiconductor veteran that won the same prestigious award as Jensen Huang and Lisa Su
BURBANK, CALIFORNIA - AUGUST 15: Protestors attend the SAG-AFTRA Video Game Strike Picket on August 15, 2024 in Burbank, California. (Photo by Lila Seeley/Getty Images)
8 months into their strike, videogame voice actors say the industry's latest proposal is 'filled with alarming loopholes that will leave our members vulnerable to AI abuse'
Orithopter shooting down another in Dune
Dune: Awakening confirms air-to-air combat in ornithopters
live action Jimbo the Jester from Balatro holding a playing card and addressing the camera
LocalThunk forbids AI-generated art on the Balatro subreddit: 'I think it does real harm to artists of all kinds'