Arm pushes back against Qualcomm in court, claiming it's not out to be a chip competitor and the current licence situation is losing them $50 million in revenue

Promotional image of a generic Snapdragon X Plus chip in a stylized circuit board
(Image credit: Qualcomm)

The Arm vs Qualcomm legal battle has been ongoing for a couple of years (can you believe it?). And while nothing's been settled, Qualcomm now seems to be assigning motive to Arm which the semiconductor and software design company has pushed back against.

According to Reuters, in court on Monday, Qualcomm's legal team argued that part of the reason for the dispute is that Arm desires to design its own chips and Qualcomm would therefore be a competitor.

Arm CEO Rene Haas was apparently dismissive of the documents presented supporting this. He said that while Arm doesn't build chips, it is always considering different possible strategies, stating: "That’s all I think about, is the future."

The dispute all started in 2022 when Arm filed a lawsuit against Qualcomm, claiming the chip company didn't have the proper licence to use some of the Arm designs it was using. These designs came from a company Qualcomm had acquired in 2021 called Nuvia. Arm thinks that, given this, all chips made using these designs should be destroyed.

Over the course of the dispute, however, Qualcomm has argued that it already had its own broad-ranging licencing rights that should cover chip production based on such designs.

Arm argues that some Qualcomm devices, such as the Snapdragon X processors, use designs that Nuvia had the licence for before it was bought by Qualcomm, but once it was bought that licence expired. Perhaps crucially, Nuvia's original licence was meant to be for server chips, not consumer ones that the designs have ended up making.

Because of this, Arm believes that Qualcomm isn't paying for the designs, despite Qualcomm's protestations that its own licencing should cover it.

The documents shown at court this week apparently showed or attempted to show that Arm has lost about $50 million of revenue because of Qualcomm's acquisition of Nuvia. That's $50 million that Arm could (so the argument goes) be getting in addition to what Bernstein analyst Stacy Rasgon (via Reuters) says is $300 million that Qualcomm already pays the company.

Both companies obviously have lots of incentive to win this court case, and I for one can see the argument on both sides. On the one hand, Qualcomm already had a licence and it now owns Nuvia, so one could argue these designs should fall under Qualcomm's pre-existing licencing. On the other hand, Qualcomm isn't paying what Arm seems to have originally intended these Nuvia-bought designs to be worth and what it originally agreed to sell them for.

Licencing is a complicated thing, and I'm glad I'm not the judge and jury presiding over this case. Especially $50 million truly is the stake at the heart of the matter.

Best CPU for gamingBest gaming motherboardBest graphics cardBest SSD for gaming


Best CPU for gaming: Top chips from Intel and AMD.
Best gaming motherboard: The right boards.
Best graphics card: Your perfect pixel-pusher awaits.
Best SSD for gaming: Get into the game first.

Jacob Fox
Hardware Writer

Jacob got his hands on a gaming PC for the first time when he was about 12 years old. He swiftly realised the local PC repair store had ripped him off with his build and vowed never to let another soul build his rig again. With this vow, Jacob the hardware junkie was born. Since then, Jacob's led a double-life as part-hardware geek, part-philosophy nerd, first working as a Hardware Writer for PCGamesN in 2020, then working towards a PhD in Philosophy for a few years (result pending a patiently awaited viva exam) while freelancing on the side for sites such as TechRadar, Pocket-lint, and yours truly, PC Gamer. Eventually, he gave up the ruthless mercenary life to join the world's #1 PC Gaming site full-time. It's definitely not an ego thing, he assures us.

Read more
Promotional image of a generic Snapdragon X Plus chip in a stylized circuit board
Arm won't keep chasing after Qualcomm on the grounds of licensing shenanigans—but the legal jostling isn't over
ARM logo exhibited at ARM stand during the Mobile World Congress (MWC).
Arm reportedly plans to make its own CPUs from this summer with future chips said to be powering a revolutionary Jony Ive-designed AI device
ARM logo exhibited at ARM stand during the Mobile World Congress (MWC).
'There are lots of tombstones of great tech companies that didn’t reinvent themselves,' says Arm CEO Rene Haas of Intel's recent woes
Qualcomm Snapdragon X Elite logo on a Samsung laptop
Eight months into the brave new world of Windows on ARM, and this is the state of play for PC gaming outside of the x86 arena
Nvidia's large presence at Computex 2023.
Anti-Nvidia crypto lawsuit will go ahead despite Nvidia's appeal, US Supreme Court rules
 photo shows a factory tool that places lids on data center system-on-chips at an Intel fab in Chandler, Arizona, in December 2023. In February 2024, Intel Corporation launched Intel Foundry as the world’s first systems foundry for the AI era, delivering leadership in technology, resiliency and sustainability.
TSMC now said not to be eyeing up Intel's fabs while other rumours suggest Intel could be split between TSMC and Broadcom
Latest in Processors
A screenshot from a YouTube video showing a sticker being pulled from the front of a fake 9800X3D CPU
This Amazon-bought fake AMD Ryzen 7 9800X3D is actually a 14-year-old Bulldozer chip with a cheap sticker on it
A close-up stylized photo of a silicon wafer, showing many small processor dies
Intel is still using TSMC for 30% of its wafer demands: 'We were talking about trying to get that to zero as quickly as possible. That's no longer the strategy'
Monster Hunter Wilds screen
Monster Hunter Wilds: Turns out updating drivers fixes brand new game. Again
Qualcomm Snapdragon X Elite logo on a Samsung laptop
Next-gen Snapdragon X2 chip rumoured to pack 18 cores and a new CPU architecture, but we're still waiting for gaming to really be a goer on the original Snapdragon X
A close-up stylized photo of a silicon wafer, showing many small processor dies
Broadcom and Nvidia are claimed to be testing manufacturing on Intel's 18A process node, and even AMD is reportedly interested
Nvidia Thor SoC for automotive
Nvidia's long-awaited Arm-based chip for PCs reportedly spotted running Geekbench very badly
Latest in News
Pedro Pascal as Joel in a coat in winter looking unhappy
'Don't you know what he did?': The truth comes out in The Last of Us Season 2 trailer
Aloy
'Creepy,' 'ghastly,' 'rancid': Viewers react to leaked video of Sony's AI-powered Aloy
Split Fiction trailer still - Zoe and Mio standing side by side, wearing glowing neon sci-fi jammies
Split Fiction sells 1 million copies over 2 days
A soldier looks out over the Verdansk map, as a single tear rolls down his cheek.
The original Verdansk map is returning to Call of Duty: Warzone, to celebrate which we get a soldier crying to Nat King Cole
More than 5 years after launch, Control gets a surprise patch that lets everyone play the Hideo Kojima mission
Swen Vincke
Swen Vincke stamps seal of approval on Stardew Valley mod that yoinks the Baldur's Gate 3 cast out of D&D and into a cosy pastoral life