A remake of strategy classic Romance of the Three Kingdoms 8 has proven divisive among its fanbase

A panoply of historical characters from Romance of the Three Kingdoms 8 Remake.
(Image credit: Koei Tecmo)
ROMANCE OF THE THREE KINGDOMS 8 REMAKE - Launch Trailer - YouTube ROMANCE OF THE THREE KINGDOMS 8 REMAKE - Launch Trailer - YouTube
Watch On

Romance of the Three Kingdoms (RT3K) is a sprawling strategy series that has changed immensely over the four decades of entries Koei, now Koei Tecmo, has released since 1985. For its vast panoply of characters and broad gameplay where you focus on a single person as your own avatar, 2001's Romance of the Three Kingdoms 8 is particularly fondly remembered not just in the series stronghold of East Asia but in the West because it got a proper release on PlayStation. The recently released remake of RT3K 8, however, is catching fan flak for being less of a remaster that respects the original and more of a remake that tries to bring in elements from the series' more recent releases.

"This is dumbed down version," reads one of the top positive Steam reviews. "Perhaps its easier for new players to enter into this genre."

Which could just as easily be a line from a negative review, couldn't it? With 1,675 user reviews on Steam at press time, just 48% of them are positive. Fans are especially willing to criticize where it's limited and repetitive compared to the original release of RT3K 8: One of the biggest complaints is the restrictive system by which in-game events, called Tales, happen. Comparisons to repetitive second and third playthroughs of a visual novel abound, a brutal condemnation for a series where variety of replays in differing starting scenarios is a key feature.

The game's AI is also taking a shellacking for being passive. That's nothing new for strategy gamers, who usually put up with lackluster AI as a genre staple, except when it's bad at its own game in a revised format players are already calling dumbed down. Players feel like they traded the nuanced complexity of the original for… nada, really, and a passive AI is no good in a game people enjoy roleplaying in as the sandbox throws surprises at them. It's not a great outlook for future remakes and remasters of a series that has a long history lots of people would probably enjoy digging into and that stands on the precipice of winning more western fans as Steam releases open it up to the greater PC gaming world.

This kind of controversy is nothing new for the series, and there are surely die-hard fans of any one of its game styles from over the past four decades. Just go look at reviews for the last couple entries for a great example: 2016's RT3K 13 is much-liked, but 2020's RT3K 14 got panned pretty hard by reviewers—including here on PC Gamer—leading most comparisons of the RT3K 8 remake to compare it to… 13, the last "good" entry, rather than the most recent one.

You can find Romance of the Three Kingdoms 8 Remake on Koei Tecmo's website and on Steam.

Contributor

Jon Bolding is a games writer and critic with an extensive background in strategy games. When he's not on his PC, he can be found playing every tabletop game under the sun.

Read more
Dynasty Warriors: Origins
Dynasty Warriors: Origins review
Civilization 7 leader image
Civilization 7 is off to a rocky start as it receives 'Mixed' Steam reviews from its premium backers: 'Comparing this unfinished mess to the Civ 6 release is night and day'
A large blue factory complex in Industrial Annihilation
Planetary Annihilation successor has a bumpy landing on Steam, and the backers aren't happy: 'So bare bones that it's basically an asset show without a game'
Suikoden 1&2 HD remaster
Suikoden 1&2 HD Remaster review
Civilization 7 review screenshot
Civilization 7 review
A still from the Civilization 7 opening cinematic.
Civilization 6 still has more daily Steam players than Civilization 7
Latest in Strategy
Maximillian from Evil Genius 2
Rebellion CEO says Evil Genius 3 could happen but wonders 'what else could we do with it other than a base-building game?'
A city from 1800
One of the best city builders of the last decade is currently 90% off on Steam
Company of Heroes 3
Company of Heroes 3 is free to try and 50% off, so it's the best time to check out the beefy 2.0 overhaul
People swimming in a pool and lying on floats
Planet Coaster 2's spring roadmap splashes down, with 'round-bottomed flumes' coming in March and buildable restaurants arriving in April
A bird's eye view of a nuclear bomb detonating in Ara: History Untold.
Microsoft's Civilization 7 competitor escalates tensions with Firaxis' embattled 4X, announcing that nukes are coming with its impending diplomacy update
Civilization 7 victory guide
Firaxis says it's 'entering our Sukritact Age' as it hires popular modder to work on Civilization 7
Latest in News
Pipboy holds up an open padlock.
A BIOS update could be all that's stopping you or someone else from jailbreaking your old AMD CPU
Pedro Pascal as Joel in a coat in winter looking unhappy
'Don't you know what he did?': The truth comes out in The Last of Us Season 2 trailer
Aloy
'Creepy,' 'ghastly,' 'rancid': Viewers react to leaked video of Sony's AI-powered Aloy
Split Fiction trailer still - Zoe and Mio standing side by side, wearing glowing neon sci-fi jammies
Split Fiction sells 1 million copies over 2 days
A soldier looks out over the Verdansk map, as a single tear rolls down his cheek.
The original Verdansk map is returning to Call of Duty: Warzone, to celebrate which we get a soldier crying to Nat King Cole
More than 5 years after launch, Control gets a surprise patch that lets everyone play the Hideo Kojima mission