One player has finally solved the Silent Hill 2 remake photos secret, and the devs couldn't be happier: 'There was a theory in our company that the puzzle might be too hard'

James looking worried
(Image credit: Konami)

Silent Hill 2's remake is full of new puzzles that players have had to tackle since launch, and it turns out that the most important one of them all has only just been solved by a dedicated fan.

"I solved the Silent Hill 2 remake photos secret," a player who goes by DaleRobinson says. "If you count things within each photo (for example, the open windows in photo 1 = 6), then count that number across the writing on each one, you will get a letter. It spells out: 'You've been here for two decades.'"

DaleRobinson was able to figure this out by doing the following: There are 26 photos you can find throughout the Silent Hill 2 remake in total, and of these contain one letter that will help decipher the answer: "You've been here for two decades." You can figure out which letter is part of the solution by counting key objects in each photo and then cross-referencing that number to the writing underneath said picture.

For example, under the first photo, the words read, "So many people here!" There are also six windows in the picture, so you need to select the sixth letter of the sentence, which is "Y". DaleRobinson has explained the workings for every single letter as well as linking to a list of every single photo present so you can double check the answer for yourself.

It's a complicated way of solving this puzzle, and even though I understand how they were able to figure out the answer for themselves, I'm not sure I'd ever be able to complete it myself, a fact that I'm not too ashamed of because Silent Hill 2's dev team thought the puzzle was too hard.

"I knew it wouldn’t stay hidden for long," creative director and lead designer Mateusz Lenart says. "(There was a theory in our company that the puzzle might be too hard) I really wanted to make it subtle when I was painting those photos... I think the timing couldn’t be better for you to solve it. Congratulations!"

The solution to this puzzle also confirms a popular fan theory that the Silent Hill 2 remake takes place in a looping story and that James is trapped in an endless nightmare. But there are other small clues that the game takes place in some kind of loop. Twitch streamer Deadhead proposed a few weeks back that you can tell the Silent Hill 2 remake is a looping narrative due to certain actions from key characters, like how Pyramid Head seems slightly more subdued than in the original game and how Maria mentions experiencing deja vu. There's also the fact that quite a few of the dead bodies scattered around Silent Hill seem to resemble James, "There were some hints in the original Silent Hill 2 of some kind of loop taking place, as many of the random human corpses looked like James," Deadhead explains.

Whether or not these small features prove the theory about Silent Hill 2 is still unclear, but at least we do know Bloober Team's intentions when it came to creating a looping story for James to suffer in for the rest of eternity.

Elie Gould
News Writer

Elie is a news writer with an unhealthy love of horror games—even though their greatest fear is being chased. When they're not screaming or hiding, there's a good chance you'll find them testing their metal in metroidvanias or just admiring their Pokemon TCG collection. Elie has previously worked at TechRadar Gaming as a staff writer and studied at JOMEC in International Journalism and Documentaries – spending their free time filming short docs about Smash Bros. or any indie game that crossed their path.

Read more
Silent Hill 2
Bloober's Silent Hill 2 was more remix than remake and that's why it was great
Silent Hill f transmission trailer screenshots
'We've been keeping fans waiting for an awfully long time': We finally got to see more of Silent Hill f and boy, does it look great
KCD 2 Peculiar Poem - Henry standing in water
Peculiar Poem solution in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2
The Talos Principle 2 screenshot
Croteam 'never planned to make' its philosophical puzzler The Talos Principle, but it emerged as a 'happy accident' while working on Serious Sam
Ten planks of wood from Dark Souls, responsible for my nightmares in Blighttown.
The co-creator of Dark Souls' most ambitious mod resurfaces to inform me that Blighttown, source of my nightmares, was cobbled together with '10 bits of wood'
An image of Alan Wake from Alan Wake 2's rock opera-style song, Herald of Darkness, lifting a hand to the sky while the other bundles on his chest.
After more than a year and 2 million sales, Alan Wake 2 is finally turning a profit for Remedy
Latest in Horror
Resident Evil Village - Lady Dimitrescu
'It really truly changed my life in every possible way': Lady Dimitrescu actor says her Resident Evil Village role was just as transformative for her as it was for roughly half the internet in 2021
Silent Hill f transmission trailer screenshots
'We've been keeping fans waiting for an awfully long time': We finally got to see more of Silent Hill f and boy, does it look great
One of Repo's player characters, resembling a yellow pedal bin with googly eyes, encounters a skeletal, open mouthed face with glowing yellow eyes.
After REPO 'kinda blew up', its developer asks the community for advice on how to make matchmaking lobbies
R.E.P.O. screenshots
REPO is my new favourite co-op horror game, which combines Lethal Company's looting loop with Content Warning's zany monsters
Blood Typers
Blood Typers is a budget-priced fusion of Typing of the Dead and co-op survival horror
Phasmophobia Bleasdale Farm rework images
Phasmophobia is getting a big rework for one of its oldest maps, turning the Bleasdale Farmhouse into a horrifying and confusing maze
Latest in News
Will Poulter holding a CD ROM
'What are most games about? Killing': Black Mirror Season 7 includes a follow-up to 2018 interactive film Bandersnatch
Casper Van Dien in Starship Troopers
Sony, which is making a Helldivers 2 movie, is also making a new Starship Troopers movie, but it's not based on the Starship Troopers movie we already have
Assassin's Creed meets PUBG
Ubisoft is reportedly talking to Tencent about creating a new business entity to manage Assassin's Creed and other big games
Resident Evil Village - Lady Dimitrescu
'It really truly changed my life in every possible way': Lady Dimitrescu actor says her Resident Evil Village role was just as transformative for her as it was for roughly half the internet in 2021
Storm trooper hero
Another live service shooter is getting shut down, this time before it even launched on Steam
Possibility Space concept art.
Possibility Space owners sue NetEase for $900 million over allegations it spread 'false and defamatory rumors' of fraud at the studio that ultimately forced it to close