Borderlands 4's new vault hunters get a mixed reaction from fans: some say they're 'bland,' others defend their excitement

Borderlands 4 - Official First Look - YouTube Borderlands 4 - Official First Look - YouTube
Watch On

What struck me about the Borderlands 4 trailer shown at The Game Awards is that the graphical fidelity has advanced so far that the comic book art style that defined the first game is fading away. It looks like the characters are doing Borderlands cosplay, with black Sharpie lines on foam props, and in the daytime scene at the start of the trailer, the signature Borderlands style is almost entirely absent from the rocky terrain.

I still think it looks great, even if the style that once set the series apart—one of the most successful pivots in videogame history—is becoming vestigial. Borderlands fans, however, had their eyes fixed on more substantial matters: the new vault hunters, whose reveal has divided opinions. The Borderlands subreddit is currently awash with both posts that call the new protagonists "bland" and counter-posts declaring that everyone is being too negative.

Four new Vault Hunters

(Image credit: Gearbox)

"The designs of the vault hunters might be my least favorite in the franchise," reads one popular thread. One of the complaints is that they're all human—no robots, no aliens. As they do the slo-mo shoulder-to-shoulder astronaut walk together in the trailer, they all have the same expression and their clothes are similar, so I get the complaint. But maybe we just haven't seen enough of them to know what makes them distinct.

Plenty of fans are pushing back on the negativity, and in fact much of the conversation I'm seeing is more about the nature of reveals and fan reactions than expectations for the game itself. "One of the greatest things I've read on here is that if you love a game, don't visit its subreddit," said one wise Borderlands fan.

It's a pretty normal response to a big reveal from a long-running series—scattered feelings of disappointment countered with variations of 'unpopular opinion: I liked it'—but it does speak to the challenge of keeping a long running series fresh. The Borderlands games have all been hits, but no series is bulletproof. There used to be armies of Halo fans who'd descend on you if you said a single bad word about the Chief, and back then I never thought I'd see the series as disrespected as it was when Halo: Infinite was revealed—that was brutal.

The Borderlands movie that finally came out this year wasn't exactly a blockbuster—we called it "an irredeemable mess"—so Randy Pitchford and company are perhaps under a little extra pressure to prove they still have it. What little movement and shooting we saw in the trailer looked fun to me, and my gut says this one will do just fine.

Borderlands 4 is set to release sometime in 2025.

Tyler Wilde
Editor-in-Chief, US

Tyler grew up in Silicon Valley during the '80s and '90s, playing games like Zork and Arkanoid on early PCs. He was later captivated by Myst, SimCity, Civilization, Command & Conquer, all the shooters they call "boomer shooters" now, and PS1 classic Bushido Blade (that's right: he had Bleem!). Tyler joined PC Gamer in 2011, and today he's focused on the site's news coverage. His hobbies include amateur boxing and adding to his 1,200-plus hours in Rocket League.

Read more
borderlands 4
Borderlands 4 gets a release date and another acrobatic trailer
Borderlands 4 teaser image
Borderlands 4: Everything we know about Gearbox's next big FPS
A woman in gold with a glowing blue visible under flowing white hair
'Borderlands 4 does have some open-world-like features,' says Gearbox, before clarifying it isn't an open world game 'in the traditional use of that term'
A screaming mechanised bandit roars a mighty bellow in Borderlands 4.
Gearbox CEO Randy Pitchford rants at internet randoms (again), insists we should 'root for' the Borderlands 4 team or 'we'll all pay the price', then whips around and says 'I love criticism'
marvel rivals
Competitive shooters are at a crucial crossroads in 2025: 'sweaty' teamplay vs. casual fun
Doom: The Dark Ages screnshot
The 11 big FPS games of 2025
Latest in FPS
CS 1.6 remade in CS: Legacy.
A gorgeous ground-up remake of Counter-Strike 1.6 is on its way to Steam, and one of the game's original creators says 'it really gives me old vibes'
Metro Exodus
'I want to raise this glass to our fans, to our community': 4A Games celebrates Metro 2033's 15th anniversary and hints at next Metro game
Official artwork of Valorant showing the game's characters in a row
Valorant dev accepts there's too much random crap cluttering up the screen: 'The balance team generally agrees with this take'
Fragpunk FPS
Fragpunk review
Battlefield 1
The best Battlefield game of the last decade is 95% off until Thursday
Grab the brilliant Doom 2016 for its lowest price ever
Latest in News
Three sheep with big guns in Palworld.
It was 'super popular to hate Palworld' after launch, says community manager: 'A lot of companies might crumble under the threats, under the pressure'
Palworld Ancient Civilization Parts - Grizzbolt with a minigun
'It was a very depressing day': Palworld community manager reveals studio's reaction to Nintendo lawsuit
CS 1.6 remade in CS: Legacy.
A gorgeous ground-up remake of Counter-Strike 1.6 is on its way to Steam, and one of the game's original creators says 'it really gives me old vibes'
Portal P3 pinball table
There's a new Portal game and it costs $12,500
MrBeast posing in front of a stack of cashing, promoting Beast Games season 2
Beast Games opens casting for season 2: MrBeast lost a ton of money on season 1 but apparently not enough that he won't do it again
Image for
Rise of the Ronin's PC troubles continue as players report disappearing saves on Steam