Destiny 2 cheat maker that clapped back at Bungie has said clapback dismissed in federal court

Destiny 2 King's Fall secret chest - Guardians with raid armor and weapons
(Image credit: Bungie)

Destiny 2 cheat maker AimJunkies has faced a major setback in its battle against Bungie today, as a Seattle federal court has dismissed its counterclaim against the developer.

AimJunkies filed the counterclaim back in September, a response to Bungie's copyright infringement lawsuit. The cheat maker accused Bungie of hacking, claiming that it combed through key member James May's computer "on several occasions" across two years to build its copyright infringement case. The counterclaim also accused Bungie of "unauthorised and clandestine surveillance of private records" on May's PC, calling it "intentional, malicious and willful."

The counterclaim appeared rather strong at the time, aided by the fact that the court had previously dismissed Bungie's initial infringement complaint against both AimJunkies and its parent company Phoenix Digital. But now, as TorrentFreak reports, the court has sided with the Destiny developer on this occasion. 

U.S. District Court Judge Thomas Zilly says it mostly comes down to a lack of evidence on May and Phoenix Digital's parts. "May has failed to sufficiently allege that Bungie accessed his personal computer and files without authorisation. To support his allegation that Bungie accessed his personal computer, May relies on a document that Bungie purportedly produced during discovery in this matter."

The document continues: "May, however, does not explain what this document is or how it evidences instances in which Bungie allegedly accessed his computer without authorization and downloaded his personal information."

The counterclaim also accused Bungie of circumventing Phoenix Digital's terms of service by reverse-engineering its software. This too was dismissed, with Zilly stating "Neither May nor Phoenix Digital allege that Bungie accessed any copyrighted work," adding "Phoenix Digital has not pleaded any facts to support that its 'loader software' was protected by a technological measure."

May and Phoenix Digital now have until November 21 to amend their claims, similar to how Bungie was offered time to amend its initially dismissed copyright infringement complaint. Whether either party will take another stab at it is unknown, but Bungie will then have until December 8 to respond if so. 

Mollie Taylor
Features Producer

Mollie spent her early childhood deeply invested in games like Killer Instinct, Toontown and Audition Online, which continue to form the pillars of her personality today. She joined PC Gamer in 2020 as a news writer and now lends her expertise to write a wealth of features, guides and reviews with a dash of chaos. She can often be found causing mischief in Final Fantasy 14, using those experiences to write neat things about her favourite MMO. When she's not staring at her bunny girl she can be found sweating out rhythm games, pretending to be good at fighting games or spending far too much money at her local arcade.  

Read more
Bungie's lawyers have to use fan videos of old Destiny 2 content in court because, well, it doesn't exist in-game anymore
UKRAINE - 2022/02/02: In this photo illustration, a Bungie Inc. logo of a video game developer is seen on a smartphone screen and PlayStation (PS) logo in the background. (Photo Illustration by Pavlo Gonchar/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images)
Sony shares examples of 'sexually charged' texts from former Destiny 2 director who claims Bungie fired him unfairly to avoid paying millions
talk to the joneses fortnite
Epic's war against the Fortnite fraudsters sees it simultaneously name and shame alleged ne'er-do-wells as its high-powered lawyers sue them
Ghost, from Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 (2022), looks bleakly at a fellow passenger in a transport.
For COD’s sake: One player’s 763-day legal quest to make Activision unban their account ends in total success: ‘Worth the effort’
talk to the joneses fortnite
Epic sues Fortnite cheater, donates his winnings to charity, forces him to publicly apologise, bans him for life, and all but sends him to his room without dinner
Dark and Darker image - guy in a suit of armor polishing some silver
Dark and Darker developer did not commit copyright infringement, court rules, but has to pay Nexon nearly $6 million anyway
Latest in FPS
Atomfall hidden cache locations - Blue fungus ravine
All Atomfall endings and how to get each one
A female druidic figure clutches a heart riven with thorns in Hunt: Showdown
'We want to increase the cost of silence': Hunt: Showdown 1896's latest update brings a new event, a massive list of bugfixes and a tougher challenge for stealthy players
Warhammer 40,000: Darktide Ogryn
Warhammer 40,000: Darktide adds a psychic horde murderzone mode and makes Ogryns even smashier
Starfield's companion robot giving a thumbs-up
Former Bethesda dev who quit Starfield to go solo says it's 'much less stressful as an indie' without daily meetings or 'office politics': it's 'very refreshing to just care about the game'
A crew of prospectors in Wildgate, featuring a robot, a rabbit man, and a small aquatic creature in a combination mech/aquarium.
Blizzard co-founder Mike Morhaime's new company is putting Sea of Thieves-style shenanigans in space with a new crew-based shooter
Team Fortress Spy being shocked
An FPS studio pulled its game from Steam after it got caught linking to malware disguised as a demo, but the dev insists it was actually the victim of a labyrinthine conspiracy
Latest in News
A screenshot from SaGa Frontier 2, showing one of the protagonists wandering through a quaint fantasy village
One of Square Enix' most underrated PlayStation-era JRPGs just shadow dropped on Steam
The titular character from Princess Mononoke is depicted riding the wolf goddess Moro and carrying a spear.
Studio Ghibli AI image trend floods social media, cheered on by OpenAI and denounced by critics as an insult to Hayao Miyazaki
Marvel Rivals tier list - Wolverine
Marvel Rivals director says a future patch will reduce the shooter's insatiable hunger for RAM: 'It's a very big problem'
Hogwarts Legacy potions professor holding a potion
An unannounced Hogwarts Legacy expansion and 'definitive edition' have reportedly been cancelled
Story of Seasons - A cahacter in a purple tuxedo stands outside in a town square talking to the player
Story of Seasons is doing another Harvest Moon remake and it might be the best the series has ever looked
Assassin's Creed Shadows change seasons - An upper-body shot of Yasuke looking cheerfully up into the distance.
Assassin's Creed Shadows puts up the 'second highest day-one sales revenue in Assassin's Creed franchise history'