Costume Quest 2 preview: Halloween goes to the bayou

Written by Matt Cabral

A love letter to All Hallows Eve, 2010's Costume Quest became a cult-favorite among adventure-RPG players and Halloween enthusiasts. My recent look at its sequel shows that developer Double Fine is giving fans more of what they want—an inspired mix of turn-based battling and trick-or-treating—while also addressing some of the original's gameplay-rooted problems.

The first thing that struck me while sibling protagonists Wren and Reynold trick-or-treated door-to-door was Costume Quest 2's new setting. The sequel trades the first game's suburban neighborhoods for a New Orleans-like city, complete with gator-filled swamps, Mardi Gras-inspired street festivals and a bayou vibe. Its cartoony art style is near-identical to its predecessor's, but the southern flavor, coupled with slick effects, like reflective puddles and glowing lanterns, give the game a fresh feel.

While I adored the first Costume Quest's whimsy, charm, and humor, its pacing issues sometimes left me sadder than a tyke with a treat bag full of apples. Thankfully, Costume Quest 2 seems to be addressing this by adding more variety to its side missions. When the costumed crew was tasked with finding an audience for a group of street performers, the optional quest didn't require much more than chatting with NPC's around town, but it cleverly played into the sequel's fresh setting and offered a welcome alternative to collecting more candy. I found traversing the first game's suburbs a bit of a chore, so I was also thrilled to discover the follow-up is making wheelies standard on all costumes. Everyone can now zip around town on the roller skate/sneaker hybrids regardless of costume.

Double Fine's also tweaking the original's too-easy combat with what they're calling “hard-corn” mode. Those who felt the first game lacked a proper challenge will want to wear the Candy Corn costume on the battlefield; the party member donning the outfit is useless, essentially cutting the player's party from three to two and therefore upping the difficulty.

The highlight of my demo, however, wasn't the costume's inability to deliver damage, but its battle captions; while standing there, doing absolutely nothing, the kernel-covered character was accompanied by text messages like “Candy Corn watches intently,” “Candy Corn has better things to do,” and “Candy Corn doesn't want the responsibility.”

My hands-off demo didn't allow me to take Costume Quest 2's turn-based battles for a test drive, but I got to see the new Clown costume in action. It looks like a cute get-up outside of combat, but things turn just a little creepy when the gloves come off. The clown flashes a gaping maw full of teeth and packs plenty of menace beneath his rainbow-colored afro. Of course, there's still some levity—the clown wields a banana, which he intentionally slips on to somehow heal the party.

Double Fine's refining and improving the franchise's gameplay, but what I'm most looking forward to is the return of the series' signature age-spanning, Pixar-like appeal. The gameplay tweaks—especially the pace-quickening wheelies—are certainly welcome additions, but it's the wise-cracking candy corn, nightmare-conjuring clown, and cool bayou-flavored setting that'll see me returning to the trick-or-treat trenches when Costume Quest 2 arrives this fall.

PCGamer

PC Gamer is the global authority on PC games—starting in 1993 with the magazine, and then in 2010 with this website you're currently reading. We have writers across the US, Canada, UK and Australia, who you can read about here.

Latest in RPG
Baldur's Gate 3 villain Raphael, staring intently at the viewer.
"Eager to get me on my knees, Raphael?" Baldur's Gate 3 mod lets you romance the silk-tongued cambion devil, although maybe you shouldn't, yeah?
A cat gets an affectionate head-scratch in miHoYo's Zenless Zone Zero.
Zenless Zone Zero developer finally embraces its divine domain as the god of jiggle physics, goes mad, adds them to cat balls
Atelier Yumia screenshot
Help, I can't move forward in this chill crafting RPG because I'm too wrapped up in building bases and making sick tools
Avowed Kai holding out his hand toward camera while explaining something to the player.
Avowed's new patch just gave you 6 more talent points to muck around with, along with a heap of fixes and improvements
Olivia, a hunter from Monster Hunter Wilds, looks perplexed in an icy blue environment.
Monster Hunter Wilds players wonder if frenzied monsters are a little undercooked, as one slaps a sickly bird into a fine paste in just 25 seconds
Sans, from the hit 2015 RPG undertale, folds his arms in a dashing suit as stonks rise in the background.
You can grab Undertale for less than $1, as the genre-defining indie RPG beats its all-time player peak for the first time in 10 years
Latest in Features
assassin's creed shadows yasuke riding a horse
Don't expect to unlock Yasuke for a while in Assassin's Creed Shadows
Atelier Yumia screenshot
Help, I can't move forward in this chill crafting RPG because I'm too wrapped up in building bases and making sick tools
midnight murder club
Five new Steam games you probably missed (March 17, 2025)
Geralt, two swords on his back, in the wilderness
2011 was an amazing comeback year for PC gaming
Alligator skull with glowing eyes on human body and cords coming out sitting at piano with "The Norwood Etudes" ready to play
My new most anticipated RPG let me be a kleptomaniac gourmand set loose in a noir city on a quest to make 'the perfect sandwich'
Monster Hunter Wilds' stockpile master studying a manifest
Monster Hunter Wilds' new gyro controls are a fantastic option for disabled and able-bodied players alike