StarCraft 2 developer AMA reveals why some things had to be cut from HotS, the problem with pro player feedback

The developers of StarCraft II: Heart of the Swarm recently did an AMA on Reddit , which brought to light some very interesting answers on everything from expansion features that didn't make it to eSports to release timetables. Game Director Dustin Browder (whom I interviewed not long ago ) took point, providing responses to some of the community's most pressing inquiries.

Perhaps among the most relevant revelations (try to say that nine times fast) was the fact that Browder himself wanted to release Wings of Liberty earlier. "[Blizzard CEO] Mike Morhaime was one of the smarter guys who stopped and said 'you need more time,'" Browder disclosed. "After working on a game for 5 years I guess you lose perspective." It presents an interesting switch-up of the familiar narrative of publishers pushing a game out the door before the devs are done.

Also interesting was Browder's criticism of the feedback top pros provided in their exclusive forum during the Heart of the Swarm beta. "The eSports forum was useful but not in the way we thought," he admitted. "Most pro players are extremely biased towards their own race (as they should be) and it was hard for us to get good feedback from them directly. But David [Kim, Balance Designer] did manage to find some pro players and casters who were more balanced in their views on the game and we have formed relationships with them directly to gather feedback."

The team also came clean on some features for HotS that were promised, but didn't end up in the shipped version. "We did a ton of changes to the rest of the UI and modifications to Aracade were relatively minor relative to the 1.5 patch," Browder said of the slated improvements to StarCraft 2's long-maligned custom map system. "I don't think we delivered on the promise."

Browder went on to affirm that he hopes the gap between HotS and Legacy of the Void is not as long as that between Wings of Liberty and Heart of the Swarm, but that "efficient and quick game development is not something we have traditionally been great at." In a closing response, he explained why StarCraft II isn't going to embrace free-to-play. "We have no plans to go free-to-play in the traditional sense. We do have a trial version that allows players to check out the game but it isn't like Team Fortress 2. Valve did make a lot of changes to Team Fortress 2 to make that game work for free-to-play. We have not yet found design choices for StarCraft II that we would be happy with to make it free-to-play, so we aren't going to do it."

You can read the compiled Q&A on Battle.net , including detailed responses from Browder, Kim, and Lead Software Engineer Alan Dabiri.

Contributor

Len Hafer is a freelancer and lifelong PC gamer with a specialty in strategy, RPGs, horror, and survival games. A chance encounter with Warcraft 2: Tides of Darkness changed her life forever. Today, her favorites include the grand strategy games from Paradox Interactive like Crusader Kings and Europa Universalis, and thought-provoking, story-rich RPGs like Persona 5 and Disco Elysium. She also loves history, hiking in the mountains of Colorado, and heavy metal music.

Latest in Strategy
Manor Lords promo art - knight on horseback looking at a medieval village in the distance, viewed from behind
PCG's best city builder of 2024 is adding a map with a gigantic hill in the middle: the perfect spot for your next castle
Maximillian from Evil Genius 2
Rebellion CEO says Evil Genius 3 could happen but wonders 'what else could we do with it other than a base-building game?'
A city from 1800
One of the best city builders of the last decade is currently 90% off on Steam
Company of Heroes 3
Company of Heroes 3 is free to try and 50% off, so it's the best time to check out the beefy 2.0 overhaul
People swimming in a pool and lying on floats
Planet Coaster 2's spring roadmap splashes down, with 'round-bottomed flumes' coming in March and buildable restaurants arriving in April
A bird's eye view of a nuclear bomb detonating in Ara: History Untold.
Microsoft's Civilization 7 competitor escalates tensions with Firaxis' embattled 4X, announcing that nukes are coming with its impending diplomacy update
Latest in News
Dante smiling
'No AI used': Netflix's Devil May Cry showrunner confirms that all of Kevin Conroy's lines were recorded before he passed
Nvidia RTX 5090 Founders Edition graphics card on different backgrounds
AI will be crammed in more of the graphics pipeline as Nvidia and Microsoft are bringing AI shading to a DirectX preview next month
Nvidia RTX 50-series graphics cards alongside an RTX 4090
Nvidia says it's sold twice as many RTX 50-series cards as RTX 40-series in the first 5 weeks. I'd bloody well hope so given there was essentially just the RTX 4090 for competition
AMD Radeon RX 9070/9070 XT graphics cards with artistic renders of reference design cards circled
Looks like a reference design AMD RX 9070 XT card has shown up in China, but let's not get carried away with thoughts of MBA cards just yet
Concept art of WoW's upcoming player housing system, showing a warm homestead with a welcoming figure in shade.
WoW flexes its MMO player housing system in a new blog post, and it really might just beat FF14's dated furniture placement into the dirt
spectre divide
Spectre Divide and its studio are shutting down after just six months: 'The industry is in a tough spot right now'